Sep 6, 2008

The Omnivore's Dilemma

A Natural History of Four Meals
by Michael Pollan

I enjoyed this book very much, but felt like it took me forever to read. The chapters were so packed with information, it made my head swim and periodically I had to set it aside and read something else, to let my brain rest and digest it all. The Omnivore's Dilemma is a detailed examination of how food gets to our tables- following the path of four different meals and then evaluating them in the final chapter of each section. Along the way Pollan talks about all different kinds of food sources- big agriculture, where corn has come to be included in almost every processed item you find in the grocery store; the atrocities of fast food (this section reminded me of Fast Food Nation); organic farming- both big, little and "off the grid" (think local and slow food movements); and surprisingly, food which he hunted and gathered himself from the forest. The part where the author followed a beef steer he had purchased himself brought to mind Portrait of a Burger as a Young Calf. There is also a lot of overlap between The Omnivore's Dilemma and things discussed in Animal, Vegetable, Miracle. Pollan shares many of his experiences conducting first-hand research: visits to feedlots and cornfields, to chicken sheds and organic farms, to tracts of forestland in pursuit of wild pig and mushrooms. This book is a lot weightier than the previous ones I've read by him, but just as interesting.

I learned so many things I can't possibly mention them all. That organic food isn't always what you might think it is. That surplus war materials have been poured into the soil: fertilizers were made from ammonium nitrate left over from making explosives, and pesticides made from chemicals originally created for napalm and agent orange. That raw fish is made safer by eating it with wasabi, which has antimicrobial properties- yay for sushi! That we know next to nothing about mushrooms- they collect energy (it is speculated) from the moon, not the sun, so don't have calories, but some lunar equivalent. I never knew.

Edited to add: I have just discovered this very interesting letter which Michael Pollan wrote in response to the C.E.O. of Whole Foods "taking issue with some of the points I have made about his grocery chain in my book."

Rating: 4/5 ........ 450 pages, 2006

more opinions at:
Ardent Reader
Book Clutter


  1. Great review! I have this on hold at the library but I'll have to read it when the hubby isn't around - We recently watched a documentary about pet food and he went nuts once he realized what we were actually feeding out animals.

  2. This sounds like such an interesting book. I confess that I'm a little scared of what I might find out while reading it, but I don't want to hide from the facts. Thanks for the review.

  3. I was buffered a bit from the shock, having already read Fast Food Nation and Portrait of a Burger... but there was still quite a lot in here to make me reconsider where I buy my food from.

  4. Anonymous9/08/2008

    I have had this book on my list for like a year and I know i should read it - I'm expecting it to be a good book for discussing!

  5. I lunar equivalent to calories! This sounds like it might be a frightening thing to read (although that should tell me right there that there is probably something wrong with my diet!!), but it also sounds like a fascinating read! I'm putting this one on the list right next to the Kingsolver one.


Comments are screened due to spam.